
Respectability Is a Racket: Kiss Tomorrow Goodbye 1950
Some noir men stumble into trouble. Ralph Cotter gets there early, sizes up the room, and figures out who he can squeeze. In Kiss Tomorrow Goodbye (1950), James Cagney plays a criminal who treats other people’s weaknesses as opportunities to get what he wants. Fear, desire, professional respectability, and power; just about everything has a price, and Cotter wastes no time finding it. The pleasure is in watching him work; the ugliness is in how little he has to work against to get it. Directed by Gordon Douglas and produced by Cagney’s brother William, the film followed White Heat 1949, offering up another vicious leading role for Cagney, but this time the menace is less an explosion waiting to happen than a calculating intelligence looking for leverage.
Harry Brown adapted the screenplay from Horace McCoy’s 1948 novel, and in the noir world nobody comes out looking clean: the crooks are dangerous, the cops can be bought, and the right lawyer can fix you up with a fresh identity.

The film opens with the survivors of Cotter’s criminal enterprise on trial, then flashes back to show how they got mixed up with him. We don’t have to wait long to find out what kind of man he is. Escaping from a prison work detail with fellow inmate Carleton (Neville Brand), Cotter kills his wounded companion rather than risk letting the dead weight slow him down.
Neville Brand gave noir’s hired muscle a vicious, unpredictable edge, whether as Chester, the pain-loving henchman in D.O.A. (1950), Steve, one of the hoods in Where the Sidewalk Ends (1950), or Boyd Kane, the hotheaded robber in Kansas City Confidential (1952). His heavies weren’t just there to throw punches, those guys made every encounter feel like it was just one wrong word away from violence. And if your love of noir reaches beyond that sensibility with an appreciation for either the instinctive artistry, untamed creativity, or the grime and rawness of ’70s cult horror, you’ll remember Brand as Judd in Tobe Hooper’s Eaten Alive 1976, a scruffy, muttering wreck of a hotel owner whose idea of handling guests involves wielding a scythe and a hungry pet crocodile.



Carleton’s sister Holiday, played by Barbara Payton, has helped arrange the escape, but she doesn’t know who actually killed her brother. Cotter keeps that to himself, uses her part in the breakout to keep her in line, and eventually becomes her lover.
Payton’s other credits take in Richard Fleischer’s counterfeiting noir Trapped (1949), opposite Lloyd Bridges, and Edgar G. Ulmer’s Murder Is My Beat (1955), in which her claim that a supposedly murdered man is still alive draws a detective into trouble. She also ventured into stranger territory with Curt Siodmak’s Bride of the Gorilla (1951), alongside Raymond Burr and Lon Chaney Jr., and Terence Fisher’s early obscure Hammer science-fiction film Four Sided Triangle (1953), playing both a woman and her artificially created double, stemming from a scientist’s solution to unrequited love that overlooks the ironic possibility of being rejected twice. In Reginald Le Borg’s Hammer crime melodrama Bad Blonde (1953), she draws a boxer into a murderous scheme against her husband, while her bigger Hollywood films include Gary Cooper in Stuart Heisler’s Dallas (1950) and Gregory Peck in Gordon Douglas’s Only the Valiant (1951).


Before he has even settled into a new life, he has already built it with blood on his hands and a lie. What follows isn’t exactly a fresh start. It’s a protection racket with room to grow. Cotter goes back to robbery with Joe “Jinx” Raynor (Steve Brodie), but the money soon attracts Inspector Charles Weber and Lieutenant John Reece, two crooked cops played by Ward Bond and Barton MacLane. They figure an escaped convict should be easy to put the squeeze on. Cotter has other ideas. With help from lawyer Keith “Cherokee” Mandon (Luther Adler), he turns their own corruption against them, keeping a secretly recorded conversation as insurance. What starts as a shakedown becomes a business arrangement, and the men who should be putting him behind bars end up helping him stay in business.

Steve Brodie wasn’t just another supporting tough guy: he had a substantial noir résumé, and he could play the ordinary man caught in the machinery as well as someone helping turn the gears. His lead in Desperate makes a particularly big difference between his criminal role in Kiss Tomorrow Goodbye. In Out of the Past (1947), he’s Fisher, Robert Mitchum’s former detective partner, whose attempt to profit from finding Jeff and Kathie makes him a pivotal figure in their unraveling. In Desperate (1947), Anthony Mann gave him the central role of Steve Randall, a truck driver who unwittingly takes a job hauling stolen goods and finds himself threatened by Raymond Burr’s gang. It’s worth mentioning because Brodie gets to carry the film as the endangered working man rather than supply the menace. His broader noir credentials include Crossfire (1947), Armored Car Robbery (1950), and Joseph Losey’s M (1951). He’s had quite a run of distinctive crime films, and here I like the contrast between Brodie and Cagney: Jinx feels like a crook who wants a payoff, while Cotter needs to dominate everyone around him.



Barton MacLane, Luther Adler, James Cagney and Ward Bond in Kiss Tomorrow Goodbye 1950.



Adler is a particularly good fit for this company. Mandon has a knack. He makes a dangerous man seem perfectly reasonable and respectable, giving crookedness a polish that makes him no less threatening. His soft-spoken racketeer Majak in D.O.A. has that same unsettling calm: a man capable of apologizing while explaining why someone has to die.
There’s a useful contrast with Adler’s role in Joseph Losey’s M (1951), where he plays an alcoholic former attorney whose climactic speech confronts the criminal underworld’s claim that they’re rightfully administering justice. Here, he is rather more comfortable helping it get organized. That’s where the film gets particularly nasty. Cotter doesn’t have to make anyone crooked. All he has to do is figure out how to make their corruption work for him.
When Jinx warns, “He ain’t to be trusted,” Cotter replies, “Why should he be different?” That little exchange tells you plenty about the company they keep. Nobody expects an honest deal. They just want to make sure they’re not the one being strong-armed. Cotter’s advantage is that he knows how the game works and doesn’t bother pretending he’s above it.
Cagney gives that recognition a wicked little spring. The clipped delivery, sudden changes of temperature, that quick, challenging grin, and coiled physical energy associated with The Public Enemy 1931 and White Heat are all useful here, but Cotter also knows how to make brutality sound almost conversational.
He can threaten a woman and then ask her for something to eat at the same time: “And now, would one fugitive from justice care to fix another fugitive from justice… a sandwich?” The pause makes domesticity another way to bare his teeth, as though surviving his company should naturally be followed by serving him lunch. Cagney’s humor does not soften Cotter’s brutality. His entitlement is right out in the open.
Payton’s Holiday gives that entitlement something volatile to work against. In her short career, already familiar with noir territory through Richard Fleischer’s Trapped (1949), Payton brings a directness that suits a woman whose grief, anger, and attachment are being manipulated all at once. In this noir, Holiday is not the cool architect of a man’s downfall. Throughout the film, she is the one being lied to, bullied, and kept in the dark. The scene where Cotter lashes her with a wet towel, only for her to embrace him, gives their relationship its ugliest shape. Whatever attraction exists between them, the film ties it to domination. Tenderness does not explain the violence away.

Kiss Tomorrow Goodbye stands out for giving her something harsher to play with than glamour alone. Her strength here is the friction between defiance and vulnerability. There is little protective elegance in her performance: it gives Holiday no polished surface to hide behind; her anger does not spare her the humiliation of still wanting him. She is brilliant at giving Holiday’s resentment a blunt edge without making her immune to Cotter’s hold. That makes the part more unsettling than a conventional femme fatale role. Holiday can challenge him without controlling him, and Payton lets that distinction hurt. She gives us a woman whose resistance and dependence keep cutting across each other. Holiday pushes back against being pushed around and deceived, but she still wants the man doing it. She can see enough to fight him without being ready to let him go.

Cotter has made his money with a gun, and soon wants more than the next haul. Now he wants the sort of life where nobody asks where the money came from. With a new identity and the protection Mandon helps arrange, he starts courting the wealthy socialite Margaret Dobson, played by Helena Carter.

Helena Carter, who would later play the reassuring Dr. Pat Blake in Invaders from Mars (1953), gives Margaret a polished assurance that sets her apart from Holiday, whose feelings have nowhere to hide. Margaret moves through the world as though doors will open for her. She expects to get her way without having to fight for it. Cotter wants to be on the right side of those doors. She offers money, connections, and a chance to wear respectability as convincingly as another man wears a good suit, with nobody looking too closely at the man inside.

Helena Carter and Jimmy Hunt in William Cameron Menzies Invaders from Mars, 1953.
Mandon warns him that Margaret’s father, Ezra Dobson (Herbert Heyes), has enough power to make him wish that he’d never laid a hand on her. Cotter marries her anyway, but her father’s intervention complicates his plans: getting into the family does not mean he gets to call the shots. But he’s hardly likely to back away from all that influence.


The marriage brings that respectable life close enough for Cotter to start making himself comfortable. Ezra wants him out of the picture, but Cotter refuses his payoff and makes the refusal look like devotion to Margaret. It is a neat bit of gall: he holds out for the whole prize and gets to look principled doing it. Margaret still loves him; the marriage is still his ticket into the family. He might just pull it off. The door is still open, and Cotter might still settle into a life where nobody calls him a criminal, provided the people who know better don’t catch up with him first. The trouble is that marrying into a respectable family does not get rid of everyone who knows how he got there.
Adler is especially enjoyable as the lawyer who helps make that fantasy plausible. A distinguished theater actor and member of the Group Theatre, with screen work including House of Strangers 1949, D.O.A. 1950, M 1951, Cornered 1945, and Crashout 1945, he gives Mandon a cultivated eccentricity that separates him from the more bluntly intimidating men around him. He gives a dirty deal the polish of professional advice.

Ward Bond and Barbara Payton in Kiss Tomorrow Goodbye 1950.

Ward Bond and Barton MacLane bring a different kind of muscle. They represent the law with its palm out. Bond’s familiar presence in films like It’s a Wonderful Life 1946 and, later, in John Ford’s The Searchers 1956 gives his crooked inspector an especially sour edge. There is no troubled conscience working beneath the badge, no moral struggle at all. He knows what his authority is worth and expects to be paid for it.



Rhys Williams is another familiar face with a terrific list of credits—Dai Bando in How Green Was My Valley 1941, The Bells of St. Mary’s 1945, Mr. Oates in The Spiral Staircase 1946, and Deacon Adams in The Strange Woman 1946. He also turns up in 1949’s The Crooked Way and Tokyo Joe, so there’s a nice noir thread running through his career, too. Included in his credits are Johnny Guitar 1954, The Sons of Katie Elder 1965 and Our Man Flint 1966. He also turned up across classic television, including Alfred Hitchcock Presents, Perry Mason, and The Twilight Zone.
Rhys Williams’s Vic Mason is a crooked garage owner who helps arrange Cotter’s prison escape and supplies the getaway car. He expects a profitable arrangement, but Cotter’s recklessness soon makes him regret getting involved. When Cotter robs a supermarket near his garage, Mason tips off the crooked cops, and that’s what brings them into Cotter’s affairs. Cotter pistol-whips Vic and dumps him into the grease pit, treating him like another piece of garage scrap.
Douglas keeps the deals and double-crosses moving without making anyone look better than they are. A prolific director whose early work included the Our Gang comedies, he went on to make Them! 1954, Tony Rome 1967, and The Detective 1968, moving between genres without losing his appetite for direct, forceful storytelling. I have a hunger for the world of those two Sinatra films, that gritty ’60s detective atmosphere where sex, power, and social hypocrisy keep dragging the investigation somewhere polite company would rather it didn’t go, and people hide their appetites under that facade of respectability.

Frank Sinatra and Jacqueline Bisset in Gordon Douglas’s The Detective 1968.
The Detective in particular has some rough, controversial scenes that can still rattle you. Tony Musante is wrenching as Felix Tesla, a psychologically disturbed man coming apart under vicious, homophobic police questioning. Sinatra’s Joe Leland objects to the other cops’ vicious brutality, but that doesn’t keep him from extracting a false confession. Tesla goes to the electric chair; Leland gets his promotion. His later admission that he knew how disturbed Tesla was makes that bargain even uglier. “I knew that poor bastard was a psychotic.… He didn’t know real from unreal. But I saw a chance for a promotion.” Then there’s William Windom’s scene, where a sexual encounter turns to murder when his character lashes out at the gay man who confronts him with desires he cannot accept. His sexual shame turns into murderous rage. The violence is disturbing, but so is the repressed rage behind it.
Kiss Tomorrow Goodbye is not as formally commanding as Raoul Walsh’s White Heat, and its schemes sometimes feel crowded and seem to pile up faster than the film can sort them out, but Douglas knows how to put people in a room and let their confrontations turn ugly. Someone wants money, protection, or a way out; someone else knows what it will cost them and how much pressure to apply. Douglas makes sure that whatever deal goes down, nobody walks away clean.
J. Peverell Marley’s black-and-white cinematography gives that ugliness a sharp, clean look. His work ranged from Cecil B. DeMille’s The King of Kings to the later 3-D spectacle of House of Wax 1953, starring the inimitable Vincent Price, but here he keeps the emphasis on faces, interiors, the confrontations, and all the trouble brewing between them, more than a continuous parade of theatrics.

The look is more hard-edged than dreamlike. Rather than dress every scene in elaborate shadows, he gives us a good look at people sizing each other up and gives Cagney room to make an ordinary exchange turn nasty and threatening. The noir atmosphere doesn’t depend entirely on darkness swallowing up the frame; it also comes from the discomfort of watching corruption carry on right out in the open. These people don’t need a shadowy alley to do dirty business; an ordinary room will do.



Cotter’s plans finally come apart where he has been most careless: with Holiday. She learns he has married Margaret, then discovers he killed her brother, which brings their relationship to its fatal conclusion. He has counted on being able to lie to her, push her around, and still keep her, but this time he cannot talk his way out. She shoots him. The courtroom scenes leave the survivors to answer for their part in his rackets, while Holiday’s final words give the title the force of a death sentence:
Holiday Carleton (Barbara Payton) to Ralph Cotter (James Cagney): “You only said one true thing in your life, and that’s when you said you were going away tonight. And you are. Many miles out of town and six feet under. All alone, with nobody to lie to. And you can kiss tomorrow goodbye.”
For Noirvember, it’s a fitting bitter goodbye. Cotter thinks that having something on everyone means no one can touch him. Anyone who might cause trouble can be bought off, threatened, or fed another lie. His death and downfall doesn’t clean up the corruption around him or undo the damage he’s done. It doesn’t redeem the world around him. It just puts an end to his certainty that he can use people up and decide when he’s finished with them. Cagney makes that swagger a pleasure to watch, and poisonous to think about, even when there’s nothing left to admire in the man himself. Cotter can try to arrange a new name, think he’s set up protection for himself, even find a place in a respectable family. The final irony is that he can try to manipulate almost everything; what he can’t arrange is another tomorrow.
This is your EverLovin’ Joey sayin’, keep your friends close and your alibi closer, I’m sure we got more noir to talk before we kiss tomorrow goodbye.
When viewing this film, some find the protagonist’s actions less manipulative and more purely reactive. Spry Sprout